What started as a single patent infringement action in the United States District Court for the Western District of North Carolina, and morphed into international litigation in four countries on three continents, was successfully resolved by Kilpatrick Townsend for client Kennametal Inc. after four years of intense litigation.

Kennametal Inc. and Sandvik AB are the top two companies in the global market for coated metal cutting tools. In 2009, Sandvik Intellectual Property AB filed a patent infringement suit against Kennametal in Asheville, North Carolina and Kennametal hired attorneys in our Winston-Salem office to defend it. We were able to get the case transferred pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a) to the Western District of Pennsylvania, Kennametal’s home venue, where Kilpatrick Townsend in the interim had filed a patent infringement suit on behalf of Kennametal against Sandvik. Thereafter, Sandvik elected to expand the litigation by commencing suit on similar foreign patents in the United Kingdom, Germany, and China. The United States litigation was handled by Dan Taylor, Steve Moore, Jason Link, Jason Wenker, and Dean Powell, and they coordinated the defense of the UK, Germany and China litigation as well.

The litigation was hotly contested and illustrates both Kilpatrick Townsend’s technical expertise and its litigation ability. In addition to obtaining an admission from Sandvik’s inventor that he failed to perform key experiments listed in the patent, Kennametal was awarded attorney’s fees for Sandvik’s blatant stonewalling in the discovery process. Thereafter, Kilpatrick Townsend was successful in achieving a ruling that Sandvik's U.S. patent was invalid, and contributed to achieving similar rulings of invalidity in the United Kingdom and Germany. After protracted negotiations over many months, the parties were able to resolve all claims. While the terms and conditions related to settlement are confidential, Kennametal was extremely pleased. The matter is but another example of Kilpatrick Townsend’s ability to handle protracted and technical global litigation successfully.

Experience Center

Match our Experience to Your Needs

View All Case Studies

Experience Highlights

Strategic patent counseling services to Red Hat Inc.
Provides strategic patent counseling services to Red Hat Inc., the most recognized open-source software company in the world. Analyzes and more
Trade secret, Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and Civil RICO litigation in Atlanta federal district court
Represented Alliance of Professionals & Consultants, a major temporary staffing company, in a lawsuit in federal district court in Atlanta more
Sovereign authority defense in National Labor Relations Board case for gaming tribe
Represented one of the most successful gaming Tribes in the country in a case before the National Labor Relations Board, defending the Tribe’s more
Retirement plan for New York City Police Department Superior Officers Council
Represents New York City Police Department Superior Officers Council with respect to its retirement plan established for officers of the New York more